Old Brooklyn, Cleveland
Homes for Sale in Old Brooklyn, Cleveland
Browse current homes for sale in Old Brooklyn, a neighborhood on Cleveland’s West Side. Search live inventory by price, bedrooms, and property type, review current market conditions, and contact The Azzam Group when you are ready to tour.
- 15+ years local experience
- RE/MAX Haven Realty
- Buyer representation across NE Ohio
Find your Old Brooklyn home
Search live MLS listings by your criteria.
$195K
Median sale
23
Days on mkt
+5.6%
YoY price
15+
Years in Business
2,000+
Units Managed
1,000+
Properties Sold
5-Star
Client Rating
Current Inventory
Current Homes for Sale in Old Brooklyn
See the latest properties available through the live MLS search.
$114,900
4408 W 57 Street, Old Brooklyn, OH 44144
3
Beds
1 | 1
Baths
1,094
SqFt
#5239650 | House
Listing courtesy of Realty Trust Services, LLC 440-427-0123
Explore more available properties in South Euclid and find the right home for your needs.
By the Numbers
Old Brooklyn Real Estate at a Glance
These figures show a competitive neighborhood market, but individual homes can vary considerably based on property type, condition, updates, and nearby comparable sales.
Median Sale Price
$185,437
Year-over-Year Change
+0.9%
Median Price per Sq. Ft.
$141
Median Days on Market
23
days
Homes Sold
140
Sale-to-List Price
100.8%
Homes Sold Above List
55.0%
Redfin Compete Score
83/100
For Buyers
Buying A Home In Old Brooklyn
Old Brooklyn homes can attract strong buyer interest, with many recent sales closing above list price. Buyers should be prepared to evaluate new listings carefully without assuming every home needs the same offer strategy.
01
Be Ready To Act
Strong listings can move quickly, so buyers should be ready to review the right property when it appears.
Check The Condition
Look closely at major systems, previous improvements, maintenance needs, and work that may still be required.
02
Compare Property Types
Old Brooklyn includes single-family, duplex, and multifamily homes, so compare recent nearby sales with similar property types before making an offer.
03
Need help evaluating an Old Brooklyn home?
The Azzam Group can help you review comparable sales, schedule tours, and understand how a property fits the current Old Brooklyn market.
Housing Stock
What Types Of Homes Will Buyers Find In Old Brooklyn?
Old Brooklyn offers a mix of established housing, with single-family homes alongside duplexes and other multifamily properties.
OLD BROOKLYN HOUSING AT A GLANCE
Established Single-Family Homes
Buyers can find older Cleveland homes including Cape Cods, Colonials, bungalows, and other traditional property styles.
Duplexes & Multifamily Properties
Duplexes and other multifamily properties are also part of the Old Brooklyn housing mix and can appear throughout the area.
Established Housing Mix
Much of the neighborhood’s housing is established, with property age, updates, and overall condition varying from one home to another.
CONDITION CAN VARY SIGNIFICANTLY
Some Old Brooklyn homes are renovated, while others may still need improvements. Buyers should compare properties by type, condition, and recent nearby sales.
Search Your Way
Explore Old Brooklyn Real Estate
Newest Listings
Homes by Price
2-Bedroom Homes
3-Bedroom Homes
4-Bedroom Homes
Single-Family Homes
Duplex & Multifamily Homes
Open Houses
Location
Living in Old Brooklyn
Old Brooklyn is a West Side Cleveland neighborhood with access to Brookside Reservation and nearby Cleveland Metroparks recreation.
Pearl Road and Broadview Road are key local corridors, supporting neighborhood businesses, services, and ongoing community development.
Neighboring Communities
Cleveland Heights, University Heights, Beachwood, Lyndhurst, Richmond Heights, Cleveland, Euclid
Parks & Green Space
Bexley Park, Quarry Park, Oakwood Green Nature Preserve, and access around Euclid Creek Reservation
Shopping & Dining
Cedar & Green, Cedar & Warrensville, and the Mayfield Road corridor
School Districts
South Euclid-Lyndhurst City Schools; part of the city in Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Schools. Verify by address.
Local Help
Local Help Buying a Home in Old Brooklyn
The Azzam Group at RE/MAX Haven Realty helps Old Brooklyn buyers search listings, schedule tours, compare nearby sales, evaluate condition, prepare offers, and coordinate the purchase through closing.
The team also has experience with Old Brooklyn properties, including single-family and duplex transactions. For broader assistance across Greater Cleveland, buyers can also explore the Home Buyer Services page.
The Azzam Group helps buyers:
- search current inventory
- schedule property tours
- review recent comparable sales
- evaluate property condition
- prepare and negotiate offers
- review contract terms
- coordinate the transaction through closing
FAQ
Old Brooklyn Buyer FAQs
Old Brooklyn is currently very competitive. Redfin reported a median sale price of $185,437 for the three months ending July 2026, with homes spending a median of 23 days on market.
The latest median sale price was about $185,437. Individual prices vary based on property type, size, condition, updates, and location within the neighborhood.
Old Brooklyn has single-family homes as well as duplex and multifamily inventory. Buyers will find both updated properties and homes where additional work may be needed.
Yes. Old Brooklyn is a neighborhood on Cleveland’s West Side, not a separate city. It should not be confused with the City of Brooklyn or Cleveland’s Brooklyn Centre neighborhood.
Choose a property from the live listings and contact The Azzam Group. The team can arrange a tour and help you compare it with recent nearby sales.
Next Step
Ready to Find a Home in Old Brooklyn?
See what is available now, compare the properties that fit your search, and contact The Azzam Group when you are ready to tour.
